I just finished three days serving as the lead instructor for America’s Credit Unions Management and Leadership Institute, one of the premier leadership programs in the credit union industry. As part of the program, several outstanding CEOs were invited to share how they think about leadership, culture, strategy, and the future of their organizations. I wrote last week about several early takeaways from the event, including authenticity, accountability, and the importance of senior leaders being personally involved in culture. This article builds on that same conversation.
The credit union industry is a good place to study differentiation because the competitive pressure is intense. Credit unions compete with one another, major banks, fintech companies, and a growing list of digital financial services providers. Many of them offer similar products, similar rates, and similar technology.
That makes developing strategy much harder, How do you create a meaningful advantage when your competitors can copy much of what you offer?
Darin Woinarowicz, CEO of Arrowhead Credit Union in California, gave one of the best answers I have heard. Arrowhead has been recognized by Forbes as one of the top credit unions in California, and after listening to him, it is not hard to understand why. Darin is a fanatic about culture. He has a strong point of view about how to run the business, and he has built the systems to support it.
One of the most important things he said is that he owns the culture.
He has key executives who own important parts of the business, and he trusts them to do their jobs. Culture, however, is not something he delegates away. He takes personal responsibility for it because he understands that culture shapes how people think, how they make decisions, how they treat one another, and how they serve members. (In the credit union industry, they use the term “members,” but for most businesses, you can simply think customers).
His philosophy is straightforward: hire highly talented people, take exceptionally good care of them, train them well, and give them the tools and resources they need.
That investment is then directed toward a single priority. In his words, “We’re a service organization first, second, third, ninth, 24th.”
That focus was tested early in his tenure when he let go of some top salespeople. They were producing results, but their behavior was pulling the organization toward a sales-driven culture. Darin was willing to give up short-term production to protect the long-term service model.
I have seen the other version many times. A leadership team says customers matter, but nearly every serious conversation is about sales goals, margin, pipeline, and short-term financial performance. Those numbers matter. No responsible leader ignores them. The problem is that when the financial measures become the dominant cultural signal, people eventually make decisions that protect the numbers even when those decisions weaken the customer relationship or damage the employee experience.
Darin’s approach lines up closely with how I think about building strategy.
My formula is that strategy equals valued differentiation multiplied by disciplined execution. To be a strong strategy, what you bring to the market must be unique and compelling, highly valued by your target customer, difficult to copy, and something you can consistently deliver with excellence.
In highly competitive industries, the number of meaningful ways to stand out is limited.
The quality of talent is a primary lever, since people drive every outcome. Culture can create separation when it builds genuine engagement and accountability. An uncompromising focus on the customer improves relevance and loyalty. Brand reflects the trust that develops from repeated experience. Data becomes an advantage when it is better, more actionable, or applied more effectively than competitors.
This connects to something Lisa Florian, President and CEO at Clearview Federal Credit Union, shared during the program. She attends every new-hire training because she knows her presence sends a clear message about culture. That is not a small thing.
It tells new employees that culture matters enough for the CEO to show up personally.
Devon Lyon, President and CEO of Central One Federal Credit Union, added another important piece to the conversation. His remarks on decision-making in the digital age reinforced the role of data as a strategic advantage. There is more data available now than most organizations know what to do with. The advantage goes to leaders who know which data matters, how to interpret it, and how to turn it into better decisions.
That makes Darin’s use of data especially interesting. He certainly pays attention to financial performance, but he also measures service, member satisfaction, internal service, and team engagement. That tells you what he is trying to build. He is not using data only to track financial outcomes. He is using data to understand the conditions that produce those outcomes.
The larger lesson is much broader than the credit union industry.
When competitors can offer similar products, match pricing, and adopt comparable technology, the question becomes whether the organization itself has become difficult to copy. That is where culture becomes a serious business issue. A culture tied to strategy, reinforced by leadership behavior, supported by useful data, and protected through difficult decisions is much harder to replicate than a product feature or a pricing move.
The question for every senior team is whether your culture is helping you win in the marketplace, or whether you are funding, rewarding, or tolerating behaviors that work against the business you are trying to build.
I’ve been nominated for the Thinkers360 Annual Awards and voting is open now. Click the image above to sign up using your LinkedIn account and vote in under 2 minutes. I’d be genuinely grateful for your support. Thank you.
Here’s the step by step voting instructions:
- Go to 👉 https://www.thinkers360.com/tl/annual_awards/voting & click Sign Up For Free in the top right corner
- Click Sign in with LinkedIn, log in, and enter the verification code sent to your email
- Click Allow to complete the sign in
- Dismiss the welcome message by clicking the X in the top right corner
- Find John Spence under Personal Excellence on the voting page and click Vote